Read Our Reviews from Top Rated Dealer In Pittsburgh, PA

Highlights from our reviews are shared below. All reviews can be viewed on the respective review sites.

Sort By:

Per Page:

Kathleen Terlecky

05/09/2026

5.00

Excellent experience. Very easy. Simply the way all car transactions should be conducted! Highly recommended. kt

Sean Suter

05/06/2026

5.00

Absolutely the best buying experience i have ever had. Brian was amazing!!!!

Dave Langbein

04/25/2026

5.00

Jay Foley

04/01/2026

5.00

Very impressed with the professionalism and honesty at this dealership. The staff made sure I understood all my options and never rushed me into a decision. The car was in excellent condition, and the pricing was fair. The entire process was quick and hassle-free. I would definitely recommend this place to friends and family.

Olivia Stewart

02/24/2026

5.00

If you want to remove negative reviews from your Google Business, contact me via my profile; my contact details are listed there. After work you can pay..

Jeremy Keep

02/21/2026

5.00

Excellent service here. Thank you Bryan!

Mark Orecchio

01/11/2026

5.00

I have purchased several vehicles from Martin Auto Gallery over the years, including a Mercedes and two Infinitis. If they did not have exactly what I was looking for, they found it for me. Every vehicle I bought was low mileage and like new. The process was always smooth and professional, and I would not hesitate to buy from them again.

Sean Keller

11/26/2025

5.00

Earlier this year I purchased a 1991 Lincoln Town Car from these folks and had it shipped site unseen to Massachusetts. Bryan and his father were happy to apply me to arrange an inspection by a local to them mechanic and even got me a great deal on shipping via their connections. In short I got a clean classic sedan with only 61k miles for a great price, and I would certainly recommend buying from them.

Bill LaGuardia

11/24/2025

5.00

Had a great experience at this small, family owned dealership in the Pittsburgh, PA adjacent town of Castle Shannon. The company has been in business for 4 decades. Currently a father and son operation at this, their second car lot/location. Brian Martin is taking over the business and he and his father Butch did their best to ensure I was satisfied with my 2017 Mini. I am an hour away from the dealership and so this was a transaction made at the dealership. All went well, with honest, upfront dealing through the entire experience. No excuses, pressure or attempt to sell anything but the car itself. The car was all they described and we made the deal. I picked the car up a few days later and it was ready to go, with a full tank of gas and a 30 day, 1000 mile guarantee. A refreshing car buying experience. Much appreciated and thank you Brian and Butch.

Shane Gilbert

10/22/2025

5.00

Brian helped me find the perfect car! Great service as well. Thanks Brian!

Scott O'Hara - 2010 Jaguar XJ

I wanted to leave a comment regarding my purchase of a 2010 Jaguar from this dealer. I worked with Marty during the purchase procedure and it was the easiest that I've ever bought a car. Marty did everything that he said that he would do. There were none of the typical salesman games that are common at other dealers. The cars are very clean and in good operating conditions. The sales atmosphere is very relaxing and things move quickly throughout the process. You can look at the inventory online, but if you want a real appreciation for the cars and the sales staff, you need to visit the showroom in Castle Shannon. You will find that it was worth the trip even if you're just looking - and don't forget to ask for Marty.

Rich Bonadio - 2018 Lexus GS

I’m pleased to acknowledge excellent service and experience I received from Marty Pistella at Martins Auto Gallery. Mr Pistella was a good listener and help us find the perfect car for our needs. I was so impressed with the service that I shared my experience with a close friend and they to had a wonderful experience at Martins Auto Gallery dealing with Marty Pistella and the supporting team at MAG. Rich B

Jeff Spriggs - 2011 Chevrolet Cruze

Jeff Spriggs - 2011 Chevrolet Cruze

I worked with Marty on this purchase. He is truly wonderful

at multi tasking, taking care of me along with incoming calls.

All along he made me feel as though I was most important.

He’s very professional + accommodating & overall made

my 1st dealing with the Gallery a wonderful experience.

George Kozlik - 2016 Chevrolet Corvette

I just purchased a 2016 Corvette. It's a beautiful car and a fair price. Greg was awsom straight up man no worries. No BS. And he is willing to negotiate with you. Very happy customer here.

Mark C - 2018 Jeep Compass

Just a quick note from a satisfied customer. Mark and Giulia My daughter found a 2018 Jeep Compass online that was at Martin Auto Gallery. I did not think we would get a good enough deal that we could afford. Then we met Marty. First impressions were unexpected. There was no pressure, no hassle and no double talk to make a purchase. He was open to questions and offered information that was useful about the Jeep. After we had the estimated price and loan rate, he called the next day with even better rates and a lower payment plan. They did all the paperwork and delivered as promised. The Jeep was clean and had a full tank of gas at pickup. Highly recommend this dealer!!

Rachel Hammond - 2016 Toyota 4Runner

I drove 5 hours round trip to check this place out and was not disappointed! Very friendly, accommodating and helpful! I highly recommend this place to anyone. Made the car buying experience surprisingly wonderful and had high quality vehicles!

Sonya Jo - 2008 Mini Cooper

My daughter was interested in a 08 mini cooper that they had... Made a call and talked to Greg about it... We had a 2 hr drive one way and Greg made sure that the car was all ready for us when we got there. Took it for a test drive did the paperwork and away we went!! Fastest I was ever in and out of a dealership... No run around on the price or anything and even had a full tank of gas that we didn't have to beg for... I wouldn't hesitate to buy there again!! Thanks so much for a great "first car" purchase for my daughter!!

Janelle Hood - 2009 Lincoln Navigator

Greg was a great salesman. They are very professional. The deal was made and it went thru quickly.

Albert Sabol - 2005 Chevrolet Corvette

Working with Greg at Martins auto gallery to close the deal on my 2005 Corvette was a pleasurable experience. Much thanks to all employees at Martins to help me work through the necessary paperwork. Also the first time experience of Gary and his partner for driving my Corvette to my home. No other dealership has offered to do that for me when I purchased a vehicle from them.

Pamela R. - 1992 Chevrolet Corvette

These guys are GREAT ... Greg our salesman was super... had vette ready for us to test drive.... and within an hour we were heading back up north with our new car!!! Was a challenge to find location but we did!!!! Yes I would buy from them again... 5 STARS from me